Analytics Made Easy - StatCounter
Rasa News Agency - Should Iran talk to US? No! But here’s what to do if it must
Sunday, August 19, 2018
Service : > Commentary
Time : Sunday, August 5, 2018
News ID: 438971
Should Iran talk to US? No! But here’s what to do if it must
Rasa - US President Trump violates American commitments under a deal with Iran. His administration launches a relatively fervent campaign to dissuade foreign business with the Islamic Republic. He threatens the country with effectively a nuclear attack. And then he says he is open to meeting with Iranian leaders with “no preconditions.”

RNA - At first glimpse, that may sound like the practice of the classic carrot-and-stick strategy: you go for a chokehold, and you loosen the grip just before any actual choking takes place. (If you happen to mean to murder, of course, you don’t loosen until after the actual choking.)


But who are we fooling? Mr. Trump doesn’t know strategy — he may not need any. (And he may even really mean to murder.)


But, as often opined, it is more likely that he is on the lookout for success. Symbolic ones will do. A much-publicized handshake with an adversary that he can play up as great statesmanship and the elimination of a threat to the nation? Great! Just great! (The prematurity of that assertion tends to be lost on Mr. Trump’s supporters. They are people who just happen to be, well, like that.)

David Ignatius of The Washington Post describes that Trumpian quality as an attempt to make yourself feel as if you have new friends on the block when old ones figure they don’t want to socialize with you anymore.


Mr. Trump’s offer for supposedly unconditional talks has been tantalizing. And it has sparked a debate inside (and outside) of Iran.

Should Iran accept, or at least consider, that offer? Is the ball in Iran’s court or in America’s?


There is one simple answer to that latter question: there just is no court (and that should put the question of the ball to rest, too). When Mr. Trump withdrew the US from the 2015 Iran deal — something the Iranian government had invested massive political capital in and the Iranian population had pinned too many economic hopes on — he demolished essentially each and every bridge.


I was a strong advocate of Iranian engagement with President Barack Obama’s administration.


Iran negotiated painstakingly for two years, in rounds of talks that sometimes left only two hours for sleep for the negotiators in the day. In the deal that was finalized in 2015, it offered unprecedented access to international monitors to its nuclear program.


Negotiations proved a success, and the resultant deal was a win-win.


But in breaking that deal, which had consumed much energy and had produced much hope (and not only for the Iranian economy), Mr. Trump gave too many Iranians a sense of betrayal.


As a result, an Iranian consensus for further negotiations with America — Mr. Trump’s America — is far too unlikely to happen. Thanks to Mr. Trump, Iranian moderates now have little to no room to maneuver. And that may have been the latent message in Foreign Minister Zarif’s Tuesday tweet that the “US can only blame itself” — and I’ll add this — if worse comes to worst.


Furthermore, while Iran already faces economic strains as a result of Mr. Trump’s withdrawal, Iranian officials still seem optimistic about European efforts to potentially keep banking and trade channels open with Tehran.

If Mr. Trump pulled out of a highly technical deal that was already in place with Iran merely because he had promised to his base to undo the legacy of his personal nemesis number one Barack Obama, and if Trumpian negotiations with North Korea have led nowhere (despite an actually much-publicized handshake), why should Iran choose to do what would be merely a propaganda victory for Mr. Trump — especially if Tehran can somehow manage the economic pains?


Of the field of relations that would have been likely between Iran and America after the historic 2015 deal — something President Rouhani must have had in mind when he recently said peace with Iran would be “the mother of all peace” — all Mr. Trump left with his withdrawal and his subsequent, effectively nuclear threat has been “scorched earth.”


Mr. Trump may know something about how to appeal to his supporters. But he sure doesn’t know anything about how to appeal to Iranians!


Even if negotiations did take place, no better deal could come of those talks than the JCPOA — the deal that Mr. Trump broke without knowing what was in it. (And the Trump administration doesn’t have the diplomatic or technical expertise to negotiate an agreement nearly as perfect.)


In that sense, going through negotiations for another deal with America — to satisfy the whim of the new leader there — would not only be meaningless but would also go against logic.


A question of logic


The X factor there is the economic realities on the ground in Iran.


If Iran’s diplomacy with Europe fails to soothe the country’s economic pains, those realities could become the catalyst for otherwise meaningless, illogical negotiations with Mr. Trump’s America.


Logic can sometimes be fluid.


But, even if negotiations did ultimately take place with Mr. Trump, communication would not be guaranteed, as has been the case in his administration’s talks on NAFTA, on trade with Europe and China, and on denuclearization with North Korea.


For Iran at least, and at least for now, indications are strong that talking to the White House’s latest occupant will be a total waste of time. For Mr. Trump and his supporters, though, it may be an empty cause for self-congratulation.


If it ever decided to negotiate, Iran would have to figure out a way to use just that shallow behavior to its actual benefit. Giving Mr. Trump the photo op for a handshake but getting him to agree to return to the JCPOA beforehand — and to stay fully committed as long as negotiations continue — may be a good start, if it proves possible, that is.


Source: Press TV



Send Comment
Name :
Comment Text:
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Palestinian Child Prisoners: The True Victims of Israeli Apartheid
Rasa - Each year, over 700 Palestinian children in the West Bank are arrested, prosecuted and tortured by Israeli military forces. Their only crime: taking part in peaceful protests against Israeli oc...
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Bahraini cleric’s continued detention political revenge
Rasa - Bahrain’s main Shia opposition group, the al-Wefaq National Islamic Society, has denounced the continued imprisonment of its prominent leader and former lawmaker Sheikh Hassan Issa as “politica...
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Marking World Humanitarian Day, UN Official Calls for Protection for Palestinians
Rasa - Coordinator for the occupied Palestinian territory Jamie McGoldrick, in the World Humanitarian Day ceremony, called for protection for the Palestinian people, particularly health workers helpin...
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Western media refuses to blame US for Yemen war
Rasa - The Western media refuses to blame the United States for the current crisis in Yemen, adding that this is why the reality on the ground has not been exposed, says an analyst.
Saturday, August 18, 2018
HRW Doubts Myanmar Probe into Rohingya Abuses
Rasa - Human Rights Watch warned that a panel set up by Myanmar to probe atrocities against Rohingya Muslims in Rakhine state does not seem to be performing its task in a “serious and impartial” manne...
Saturday, August 18, 2018
US condemned for supplying bombs to Saudis
Rasa - Americans have taken to social media to condemn the US government for supplying the Saudis with bombs used to kill innocent children in Yemen.
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Saudi writer critical of UAE’s regional policies sentenced to 5 years in prison
Rasa - Saudi authorities have handed down prison sentence to a writer in the conservative oil-rich kingdom as part of a widening crackdown led by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman against Muslim preach...
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Qatar accuses Saudi Arabia of barring Hajj pilgrims
Rasa - Qatar has accused Saudi Arabia of barring its citizens from performing this year’s Hajj pilgrimage amid a year-long boycott of Doha by a Saudi-led bloc of four Arab nations.
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Syria slams 'despicable' Saudi support for US ploys in war-torn state
Rasa - Syria has blasted Saudi Arabia for giving money to the US-led coalition to press ahead with what Damascus has described as "destabilization plots" in the war-torn country.
Saturday, August 18, 2018
UN chief proposes military force to protect Palestinians under Israeli occupation
Rasa - UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres has put forward options meant to protect Palestinian civilians, among them the deployment of an armed military or police force to the occupied territories....
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Muslim couple denied Swiss citizenship over handshake
Rasa - A Muslim couple in the Swiss city of Lausanne has been denied citizenship over their refusal to shake hands with members of the opposite sex.
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Saudi Dissident Figure: Bin Salman under Israeli Training on How to Massacre Civilians
Rasa - Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman deliberately attacks civilian targets in Yemen to break the resistance of the Yemeni army and Ansarullah, a prominent Saudi dissident living in exile in L...
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Countdown to Hajj: Rituals of biggest Muslim event
Rasa - Muslims from around the world have converged on holy sites in Saudi Arabia, prepared to begin the annual Hajj pilgrimage on Sunday, August 19.
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Bomb that killed Yemeni kids supplied by US: CNN
Rasa - Munitions experts have confirmed that a bomb used by Saudi Arabia in last week's attack on a school bus in Yemen that killed dozens of children had been supplied by the US.
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Israel’s Closing of “2014 Massacre Probe” Has No Legal Value: Hamas
Rasa - The Hamas Movement described the Israeli military advocate general’s decision to close the investigation into the army’s 2014 massacre in Rafah as “of no legal or political value".
Saturday, August 18, 2018
Army Keeps Rolling on ISIL Centers in Badiyeh of Sweida
Rasa - The Damascus Army kept on storming ISIL's positions in Badiyeh (desert) of Sweida, and captured more areas while inflicting more casualties on the terrorists over the past 24 hours.
Friday, August 17, 2018
Iranian nation will never give permission to the officials to hold negotiations with the ‘Great Satan’: Sa’idi
Rasa – Ayatollah Sa’idi said, “By following the Supreme Leader, the proud, powerful and revolutionary Iranian nation will never give permission to the officials to hold negotiations with the ‘Great Sa...
Friday, August 17, 2018
Negotiating with the spiteful enemies only adds to Iran’s problems
Rasa – The representative of Khorasan Razavi in the Assembly of Experts argued that any negotiations with the malicious enemies would indicate weakness and stressed, “The authorities must not assume t...
Friday, August 17, 2018
US Press Freedom: Debunking the Myth
Rasa - To expose the myth of a free press in the United States requires a more grounded sense of how the international press operates and is treated in the land of the free. It also requires a more ca...
Friday, August 17, 2018
Pope Francis expresses his support for victims of US 'predator' priests
Rasa - Head of the Roman Catholic Church, Pope Francis, has voiced his support for the victims of "predator" priests in the United States amid mounting accusations of cover-up and leniency.